water for elephants book vs movie

More of Jacob as an older man. I read the book back in October on the way home from New York – between the airport layover and actual flights, I finished it in one day. What kind of news would you like? Was Amsterdam charming? August is head of the menagerie AND the ringleader of. Photography. This time it’s Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen. In the novel, Gruen created that interesting fact of history into a memorable character who responds to Polish. Both square off in the ring again as Box Office Prophets presents another round of Book vs. Movie. When that fell through, she decided to get into fiction. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. SD. I confess to never having read or watched this!   Guilty as charged! But here’s a break-down of which format did what better: Rosie (the elephant) was adorable in both. First Name They are fun and theatrical and become some of your best friends in the book. Maybe I’ll give it a try one day. The Movie In principle, Francis Lawrence’s Water For Elephants covers the exact same ground as the book. For example, the geriatric version impatiently counts the minutes for his family to visit and escort him to the circus which arrives to town. ( Log Out /  I realize that because a book is none visual like a movie, it would be impossible to show the prologue exactly like it is in the book without creating some sort of mystery. You’ll be damned if you do, and damned if you don’t. Robert Patterson, played the circus vet and completed the love triangle surprisingly well. The book begins with the end of the story in the past - the stampede and then goes into the details leading up to the stampede. It’s a nice package. Did a better job of painting a picture of Depression-era America. Having read your post and all the comments, I will definitely read the book! It was a complete disaster, and I think they did the scene justice in the movie. Continued: by Cindy Bruchman. Robert Pattinson. He tried to stop younger Jankowski from stealing his wife.   Marlena knows Jacob is putting down Silver Star but August doesn't know. While I appreciated the culture of the circus, I thought the protagonist as the young narrator was flat. It kind of glossed over some of the side storylines regarding Jacob’s fellow circus workers (pay issues, illness from jake, red-lighting). Visually aesthetic. Thanks Deanna! Initially rejected by the publisher of her first two novels, a different publisher picked it up and promptly turned it into a New York Times bestseller. Water for Elephants. It jumped between present-day Jacob and his memories a bit too much. I love this book, but was less enamored with the movie. I enjoyed them both, but for different reasons. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. 3. I cite the film version of Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. It is a fast read that someone can read in a day if you have the time to just sit down and read it (or if you’re a faster reader than me which I’m assuming almost everyone is). Did Paris capture your imagination? I hate to say I haven’t read the book or seen the film, despite the attraction of RP. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. As for films which are better than books I think there are more of them there then people suspect, for example, ‘One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest’, and ‘The Virgin Suicides’ film was I think as good as the book, if not much better. The crowd was freaking out, people were getting trampled, the animals were running everywhere hissing, screaming, and more. I hope to hear of your adventures/pictures. Is Water for Elephants literary fiction? Consider the commercial success of The Lovely Bones or Secret Life of Bees and compare them to literary masterpieces like Middlesex or The Handmaid’s Tale. In this corner: the Book. I read the book in two days and a day later went and watched the movie. Hope you two had a lovely time. As far as Cuckoo’s Nest, I have to disagree. Middlesex was a masterstroke of fine writing. The story is fluently truncated from the extended length of the book into a simple two-hour film courtesy of screenwriter Richard LaGravenese (The Horse Whisperer, The Mirror Has Two Faces.) ( Log Out /  I just don’t feel any chemistry between Pattinson and Witherspoon, I think the elephant outshines pretty much everyone in this movie! Rosie the elephant was the best character of all . After watching the movie, I decided that the book was still better. ( Log Out /  Still a good ending, though I found it less believable in this format. The acting was fantastic, they did an awesome job of bringing the circus to life, they went along with the book (for the most part), and you liked the characters you were supposed to like and you didn’t like the characters you weren’t supposed to like. You really fall in love with Jacob as an elderly man in the book and it also helps you realize how some older people feel when they are in a nursing home. Tips to keep in mind for World Mental Health Day But I would say that the very best a movie can hope for is to be as good as the book. For the most part, the storyline was the same. Both square off in the ring again as Box Office Prophets presents another round of Book vs. Movie. Only days away from finishing his degree and becoming a certified vet, Jacob learns that his parents have been killed in a car accident. I do agree it was a good adaptation, but for me the book was riveting and the movie was just so-so. Put off reading until out of everything else. New at BOP:Review: Into the LabyrinthReview: RebeccaThe Amazing Race 2020 Recap#1 Movie in AmericaReview: The Trial of the Chicago 7The Amazing Race RecapReview: The 40-Year-Old VersionNew Trivia QuestionAll site updatesShare & Save Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. His cruel treatment of everything around him including his wife made the love-triangle obvious. Water for Elephants sustained my interest, and there were parts that shimmered with authenticity. I'm going to assume that you meant to say "should NOT be left out" and I completely agree. My verdict: I really liked the movie! Her knowledge of the equestrian world helped propel her first two horse-based novels to a publisher and commercial success. starring Gary Sinese and John Malkovich. I was going to the event and curious to read her work to consider her talent. The "ruined" label too is also thrown aro Read book, then movie, be disappointed. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. One is the elder narrator, Jacob Jankowski, and the second is Rosie, the pachyderm cow. Unlike so many others, Gruen actually managed a fair amount of nearly immediate success as a fiction author. I knew I'd want to see it, and I have to read the book before I watch the movie. Overall, the movie was mediocre due to the banal script and lack of emphasis on the intriguing circus culture. –Benjamin Franklin, If opportunity doesn’t knock, build a door.–Milton Berle, Don’t judge each day by the harvest you reap but by the seeds that you plant. Other strengths of the film were Rosie the elephant and watching the workers erect the circus tent. Where to start is the key question here. When the circus acquires an elephant for a … Lost a lot by eliminating older life of main character and his closeness to all the animals. I was hoping they would have set it up more like The Notebook with having the flashes to Jacob in the nursing home talking or thinking about his time as the circus and then flashing back to the past when he was on the circus. When the circus acquires an elephant for a new act, it changes everything. The movie is never better than the book IMO. Sara Gruen managed to create another memorable character by personifying an elephant named Rosie. He added the believable depth that was missing from the book as the manic-depressive, alcoholic tyrant husband to his Barbie-doll wife played by Reese Witherspoon. Christoph Waltz is cruelly … I think that you will enjoy the movie if you haven’t read the book, I am biased and want to say that you would hate the movie without reading the book but I know that’s not true. Terrific review, Cindy, of both film and book. He meets the owner of the circus, Charlie, and he tells him about his time with the Benzini Brothers. Time for another Book vs. Movie! –Eleanor Roosevelt, Either write something worth reading or do something worth writing. He is portrayed as a bit of a rebel, arguing with other residents, complaining about the food. A really good read that pulls on your heartstrings and makes you laugh. A collection of words that represent ideas when filtered through the lexical systems in a human brain. Gruen did a great job creating a cantankerous character who, for all his bluff and animosity, is a gentle, scared man who is reduced to tears. From clay tablets to bound collections of wood pulp to units of stored data, the book has been around in one format or another for some 3,800 years. It’s the story of Jacob, who runs away to the circus during the Depression when his life falls apart around him. I really liked the stampede scene when all the animals are somehow released into the circus. I decided to not watch the movie when I heard it was coming out simply because I didn’t want to possibly ruin the experience I’d had with the book if the movie wasn’t up-to-par. It was exactly what I expected, and the suspense between August, Marlena, and Jacob was interesting to watch. Sookie Stackhouse Read Along (Click for Details), Just a way to share two of my favorite pastimes…. But most likely not the book. Nah you can’t convince me, sorry! Her knowledge of the … Now this is getting a bit long, sorry, but I have a few things I must reiterate that I either said in this review or my review of the, Comparison: Water for Elephants Book Vs. Movie. When Jacob first arrives on the circus in the book, Uncle Al sticks him in a room with a man named Walter. The end of the book was pretty chaotic. Hi Tom, well, the book is good with masculine characters and so feels more than a Nicholas Sparks book. The book, the film just didn’t do it for me. As time progresses in the novel, Walter and Jacob become friends. . Author Sara Gruen was a featured speaker at the 2011 AWP Conference held in Washington D.C.I was going to the event and curious to read her work to consider her talent. Water for Elephants is one of my most favorite books. Reese Witherspoon turns 36 this year.) 1 I really enjoyed them both but I don’t think I would have liked the movie as well if I hadn’t read the book first and known all the little stories and the background on all of the characters. WATER FOR ELEPHANTS-- 2 STARS Whether it's Harry Potter, Tom Clancy spy tales, The Da Vinci Code, a measly comic book (ahem, excuse me, graphic novel), or a classic piece of fiction from a century ago, once a literary work gets annointed to become a movie on the big screen, the fan outcry of "the-book-is-better-than-the-movie" gets played to death.. Walter is a performer for the circus, and it is an unwritten rule that working men and performers DO NOT room together on circuses. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. The premise for her novel is unique and interesting with a historical edge that adds weight to an otherwise typical love-triangle plot. A lot of the big events were included, like when Jacob discovers that Rosie understands Polish, when Marlena and Jacob dance and kiss after the mob came to the nightclub, and Rosie running away from the circus once. Book vs. Movie: Water for Elephants I decided to read Water for Elephants when I started seeing commercials for the movie. I honestly didn’t mind the brutal ending…is that cruel?

Alberta Road Test Reopening, Eastern Michigan University Dorms, Multi Level Marketing Php Script, Ford Transit Timing Chain Tensioner Reset, Peugeot 208 Manual Online, Most Abundant Gas Emitted From Volcanoes, Connecticut Ivy School Grad Crossword Clue, Lucid Dreams Cause, Eastern Michigan University Dorms, Swing Door Drawing, Most Abundant Gas Emitted From Volcanoes,